I’ve never had any particular affinity for Richard Strauss, but these are decent performances. “Death and Transfiguration” is my favorite here, the rest can be a bit too melodramatic for my tastes.
The most amazing feat of Scott Walker’s later career has been to have the most unlikely popular audiences receive it so well. Since Tilt in 1995 his music has adopted experimental, operatic elements that lack the syncopation that is foundational to pop music of the rock era. The Drift added an increasingly ominous and dark tone to what already was frighteningly unique music. With Bish Bosch, Walker is flirting again with syncopation, fitfully at times, but with its programmed drum beats and proto-metal electric guitar it provides a more direct link with (fairly) contemporary pop music than anything he’s released in nearly 30 years. On top of that he’s able to pull together the resources to have orchestration on an album this “out”. Yet, he still manages to have his sense of humor felt quite directly. His previous album The Drift had surreal, absurdist lyrics like “I’ll punch a donkey in the streets of Galway” (“Jolson and Jones”) but Bish Bosch goes for a more heady mix of lowbrow phrasings with lyrics like “I’ve severed my reeking gonads/ Fed them to your shrunken face” (“SDSS1416+13B (Zercon, a Flagpole Sitter)”). To pull all these elements together in a way that holds together and finds more than scattered audiences at the fringes is no mean feat, and it’s the mark of a master that Walker has done it, again. There is definitely a brutality in the world of 2012 and Scott Walker seems to have his finger on that pulse in a way that is as unsettling and uncomfortable as the times themselves. What Bish Bosch reveals, though, is a sense of hidden value in the grotesque, an affirming quality that with a lot of effort–and with the enormous cast of players here, that’s an understatement–people have the power to reclaim the very foundation of the grotesque and create from it a new context. It’s quite telling that Walker’s approach means an engagement of the highbrow with the lowbrow, and that a gap between those audiences music be bridged. Granted, he has not won over all listeners, but in a philosophical sense, he’s re-imagining the meaning and possibilities of the path he sets out upon. It’s not just a different arrangement of the same old elements, but a bold new system of determining what is real and what is illusion. That is to say that listening to this sort of music can change how to listen to other things, and change your perception of what you have already heard. It seems the role of philosopher king suits Scott Walker well in his advancing years.
Lotte Lenya was, in a word, inimitable. That voice, so frail yet so unshakable, gave us the definitive interpretations of Kurt Weill‘s music. Lotte Lenya singt Kurt Weill was recorded in 1955 as her career saw a revival thanks to a new English-language production of Brecht/Weill’s “Threepenny Opera” by Marc Blitzstein at the Theatre de Lys (co-starring Bea Arthur, Ed Asner and Jerry Stiller). She recorded in Berlin, returning for the first time in twenty years. That environment was likely crucial to the record that resulted. A lot had changed in those years.
First some history. Germany and Prussia, under Kaiser Wilhelm II, provoked the Great War (World War I) by seeking to enjoy the same economic and political privileges that imperial powers like France and England sought to reserve for themselves. Germany/Prussia was eventually defeated due primarily to the fact that the United States lent its fiscal and manufacturing support to the side of the Allies — in spite of the Bolshevik Revolution that withdrew Soviet/Russian troops from the ridiculous conflict (not to mention allowed the publication of the secret Allied treaties in Pravda). That particular war lead to abdication by Wilhelm II in 1918, and later the Treaty of Versailles in 1919. The treaty has lived in infamy, as it memorialized the old grudges held by England/France against their counterparts with oppressive reparations imposed on the Germans/Prussians. To the chagrin of the Allies, American boorishness reared its head as the United States refused to treat Allied support as wartime grants not to be repaid (as was long tradition among warring nations) but instead as loans to be repaid (thanks to American intransigence and other factors like inept British negotiation, the terms of the loans worked out after the war were, to say the least, oppressive). (Read about this in Michael Hudson‘s Super Imperialism: The Origin and Fundamentals of U.S. World Dominance (New Edition)). This set the stage for Weimar Germany, the Republic established out of the confusion following Wilhelm II’s abdication that lasted barely more than a decade until the Nazis rose to power in 1933.
Weimar Germany was a strange and unusual thing. German reparations were so oppressive as to eliminate the possibility of economic recovery. Moreover, repayment of the outrageous Allied loans was realistically tied to and dependent upon the payment of German reparations — despite self-serving American denials. In that economically savage context, with recovery impossible, the German people lived a chaotically vibrant but inescapably desperate existence. The classic novel of the Weimar era, Alfred Döblin‘s Berlin Alexanderplaz: Die Geschichte vom Franz Biberkopf [Berlin Alexanderplatz: The Story of Franz Biberkopf], portrays the times as well as anything (the relatively lazy can instead watch the 15+ hour adaptation Berlin Alexanderplatz by New German Cinema director Rainer Werner Fassbinder). Like the novel’s protagonist, good intentions fall prey to grim realities, and crime and prostitution become familiar responses to a life of limited opportunities. Disgusting Nazi propaganda becomes a repository for misguided resentment and wounded pride, or, in Biberkopf’s case, simple gullibility.
Kurt Weill and Lotte Lenya (married to each other twice) rose to prominence in this Weimer era. Weill was a composer like Erik Satie or George Gershwin, seeking to bridge the gap between popular music and formal, classical composition. Weill has been frequently compared to Mozart for the direct, lyrical qualities of his music, so simple but with a rich and nuanced depth underneath.
The music of this album comes from a number of Weill efforts: “Die Dreigroschenoper [The Threepenny Opera],” “Aufstieg und Fall der Stadt Mahogonny [The Rise and Fall of the City of Mahogonny],” “Happy End” and “Das Berliner Requiem [Berlin Requiem]” with texts by Bertolt Brecht and “Der Silbersee, Ein Wintermärchen [The Silverlake, A Winter’s Tale]” with texts by Georg Kaiser. What makes these particular recordings so wonderful is that the music is an honest and grim interpretation of Weill’s music. When he originally scored “The Threepenny Opera,” he did not use a full orchestra. Instead, the music was for seven musicians asked to play a total of twenty-three different instruments. Alex Ross, in The Rest Is Noise: Listening to the Twentieth Century, writes that “by asking his performers to take on so many roles, Weill guarantees that the playing will have, in place of soulless professional expertise, a scrappy, seat-of-the-pants energy.” In that, one finds some of the essence of Weimar Germany, just like Franz Biberkopf the working-class protagonist of Berlin Alexanderplatz shifts his career among that of a pimp, necktie clip salesman, shoelace drummer (door-to-door salesman), newspaper barker, burglar. Biberkopf’s determined but futile individualism has the same spirit as in Weill’s ingenious, street-wise compositions.
These particular recordings, with instrumentation like a ragged banjo and warbling organ on “Moritat vom Mackie Messer [The Ballad of Mack the Knife],” or an out-of-tune piano on “Bilbao-Song,” are true to the original Weill vision. It is great that Brecht and Weill’s song has become something of a standard, but the slick renditions of Louis Armstrong, Bobby Darin, Ella Fitzgerald and others miss something when the sense of fear and uncertainty is swept away with a very refined pop/jazz arrangement. These 1955 recordings bring out something in Lenya’s voice too. Recording amidst a once-grand city ruined by Allied terror campaigns, the sense of grim desperation that so characterized Weimar Germany just below the surface in the 1920s is palpable in her rough-hewn and gently aged voice. The Great War (WWI) killed untold people, but the civilian infrastructure of Europe was largely untouched. World War II changed that. American callousness led the Air Force to switch to terror bombing of civilian targets starting with Berlin, then on to the fire-bombing of Dresden (memorialized in Kurt Vonnegut’s The Slaughterhouse Five, or The Children’s Crusade: A Duty-Dance with Death) and Tokyo, the dropping of napalm on Royan, France (read Howard Zinn, who participated as a bombardier), and culminating with the atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki (later revealed to have been unnecessary in view of a Japanese willingness to surrender, but advanced to try to intimidate Stalin; read Tsuyoshi Hasegawa, Racing The Enemy: Stalin, Truman, and the Surrender of Japan, Gal Alperovitz, The Decision to Use the Atomic Bomb or Moshe Lewin, The Soviet Century or even Peter Kuznick) — for their part the other war powers had their own instruments of terror, from the German Paris Gun and V-1 and V-2 rockets to the Japanese explosive devices delivered to mainland North America on balloons carried in the jet stream. In spite of the Wirtschaftswunder, or German “Economic Miracle” of the post-WWII years made possible by cancellation of German internal debt (and with U.S. aggression in the Korean War serving to bolster the German economy), Berlin was still in visible ruins when Lenya returned (for more context, watch Fassbinder’s Die Ehe der Maria Braun [The Marriage of Maria Braun]). However, the Berlin Wall, erected by the East to keep out CIA saboteurs (read William Blum Killing Hope: U.S. Military and C.I.A. Interventions Since World War II (Updated Through 2003)), was still six years away.
In such a brutal century, Brecht and Weill’s murderous Macheath, the central character of “Mack the Knife,” seems like a sign of the times. His knife, so the lyrics tell us, is out of sight, like the airplanes and rockets bringing down fire on civilians, or the economic subterfuge of government reparations and debt that invisibly suppressed the Germans, French and English in the Weimar era. That is the way of Brecht’s theatrical vision. Songs like “Alabama-Song” too (with lyrics some allege were co-written by Brecht’s girlfriend Elisabeth Hauptmann) capture pub life (during an era of American Prohibition), with deadpan refrains of “Oh don’t ask why / Oh don’t ask why.” The words also tell of looking for a dollar, or else they, the singers, “must die.” The contrast of the merciless themes and the seemingly light, sing-along performance throw light on the odd complexities of modern life. Times have changed less than it may seem, only the origins of those realities are more concealed than ever.
Later attempts to make music ostensibly like this so often resort to irony. There is no irony here. There are contrasts, and dialectical devices, but everything is a direct representation of what is expressed. This is music like little else.
Recorded at two performances, one on each coast (at The Troubadour in Hollywood and The Bitter End in New York City), Donny Hathaway’s Live takes on an intimate small-club feel throughout. The songs recorded on the West Coast would seem to come first. They have a smooth gloss. The songs that seem to come from performance in New York retain more brutal space and gaps. Regardless of where any one song was recorded, the entire collection presents a varied, evocative look at soul music from one of its greatest interpreters.
Donny Hathaway, still in his twenties, was perhaps the most intellectual soul or R&B performer of his day. Well, that may be misleading. He was among the most mature. Depth and clarity are ever-present in his music. The complexity of a song like “Hey Girl”, for example, is of no concern. It is effortless. Simple in its relation to the fervor of feelings sought, lost, held, doubted by practically all of us, the song’s evocation of an uncertain relationship is an experience in itself. That is the near miracle of the album. Every listen makes the present day seem to stretch out forever.
Carole King‘s “You’ve Got a Friend” (popularly recorded by James Taylor) is a transcendent moment. For quite a while, Donny lets the audience carry most—not just some—of the vocals. There is a complete communion between those who began as separate groups of performers and audience. The union happens almost immediately. Hathaway gracefully lays out the first few chords on his electric piano and a cheer immediately rises. Just the first few seconds of that song are enough to restore a sense of purpose in the most lifeless among us. Hathaway’s confidence, poise, determination and generosity are evident.
Another spectacular cover is John Lennon‘s “Jealous Guy”. Whimsical guitar and piano riffs punctuate Donny’s patient vocals. Like all his music, there is a warmth too rarely found elsewhere. Also, Donny shows he can downplay his gospel roots and still succeed in every way.
“Voices Inside (Everything Is Everything)” stretches out over four movements, with each lending an opportunity for different musicians to step to the front (like guitarists Mike Howard and Cornell Dupree, and “the baddest bass player in the country” Willie Weeks), each movement also lending to a changing emotional interpretation of the song. Certainly the funkiest number on the album, the extended (thirteen minute) performance highlights what an accomplished soul-jazz combo was at work.
Though plagued by severe depression through much of the coming years, the period when Live was recorded was Donny Hathaway’s creative peak. In his last years, Donny recorded little. His duets with Roberta Flack from the early 1970s–“Where Is the Love?”, etc.–found the most widespread popularity. Still, it will be Donny’s own records that will endure longest.
It would be too much to say this is one of the greatest albums ever made. There are no final greatest masterpieces. Contexts change. Even still, hell, Live is as close to the top of the heap as we’ll ever know.
Lester Bangs lamented that The Electric Flag got buzz in the press when more deserving acts languished in obscurity (in spite of Bangs’ best efforts). There is just something disingenuous about The Electric Flag. Yeah, they have a jazzy soul thing going, melded with slightly psychedelic blues rock. But it seems too crass, just an assemblage of whatever seemed “hip” at the time. It’s contrived. These guys would have made a great studio band for somebody else, but on their own they just don’t have any good ideas of their own, just the ability to loosely amalgamate popular styles of the day. It’s the kind of music they seemed obligated to make, not music that came from any kind of genuine passion or drive outside of rock careerism. This just clings to forms that already had matured in the hands of others. But, for what it’s worth, this album beats the seemingly better-known A Long Time Comin’. Reference The Rascals too.
My selections for a “virtual” compilation of music by Johnny Cash, in the spirit of Bob Dylan‘s Biograph. In other words, this steps out from the usual canon of accepted Cash classics and presents some of the hits together with non-single deep album tracks, live recordings, B-sides, demos, and other overlooked treasures. Don’t consider this exhaustive. There are plenty of great Cash recordings not featured here. The list provides links to single releases, if any, plus the first album releases.
- “I Walk the Line” (1956); Johnny Cash With His Hot and Blue Guitar! (1957)
- “Folsom Prison Blues” (1955); Johnny Cash With His Hot and Blue Guitar! (1957)
- “I Was There When It Happened” Johnny Cash With His Hot and Blue Guitar! (1957)
- “The Wreck of the Old ’97” Johnny Cash With His Hot and Blue Guitar! (1957)
- “Hey, Porter!” (1955); Now Here’s Johnny Cash (1961)
- “Get Rhythm” (1956); Greatest! (1959)
- “Big River” (1958); Sings the Songs That Made Him Famous (1958)
- “Five Minutes to Live” The Man in Black: 1959-’62 (1991)
- “Guess Things Happen That Way” (1958); Sings the Songs That Made Him Famous (1958)
- “The Ways of a Woman in Love” [alternate version] Roads Less Travelled: The Rare and Unissued Sun Recordings (2001)
- “Goodnight Irene” Original Sun Sound of Johnny Cash (1964)
- “I Still Miss Someone” (1958); The Fabulous Johnny Cash (1958)
- “Swing Low, Sweet Chariot” Hymns by Johnny Cash (1959)
- “Drink to Me” Songs of Our Soil (1959)
- “The Great Speckled Bird” Songs of Our Soil (1959)
- “Seasons of My Heart” (1960); Now, There Was a Song! Memories From the Past (1960)
- “Transfusion Blues” Now, There Was a Song! Memories From the Past (1960)
- “The Rebel – Johnny Yuma” (1961); Ring of Fire: The Best of Johnny Cash (1963)
- “In Them Old Cottonfields Back Home” The Sound of Johnny Cash (1962)
- “A Little at a Time” (1962); Old Golden Throat (1968)
- “Were You There (When They Crucified My Lord)” (1962); Ring of Fire: The Best of Johnny Cash (1963)
- “The Talking Leaves” Bitter Tears: Ballads of the American Indian (1964)
- “As Long as the Grass Shall Grow” Bitter Tears: Ballads of the American Indian (1964)
- “Custer” Bitter Tears: Ballads of the American Indian (1964)
- “Ring of Fire” (1963); Ring of Fire: The Best of Johnny Cash (1963)
- “Understand Your Man” (1964); I Walk the Line (1964)
- “It Ain’t Me, Babe” (1964); Orange Blossom Special (1965)
- “Don’t Think Twice, It’s All Right” Nashville at Newport (1995)
- “Ballad of Ira Hayes” Nashville at Newport (1995)
- “When It’s Springtime in Alaska (It’s Forty Below)” Orange Blossom Special (1965)
- “Mr. Lonesome” The Sound of Johnny Cash (1962)
- “The Road to Kaintuck” Sings the Ballads of the True West (1965)
- “Happiness Is You” Happiness Is You (1966)
- Johnny Cash & June Carter “Fast Boat to Sydney” Carryin’ On (1967)
- “Folsom Prison Blues” (1968); At Folsom Prison (1968)
- “Dark as the Dungeon” At Folsom Prison (1968)
- “Flushed From the Bathroom of Your Heart” At Folsom Prison (1968)
- “Jackson” At Folsom Prison (1968)
- “I Got Stripes” At Folsom Prison (1968)
- “Greystone Chapel” At Folsom Prison (1968)
- “Tennessee Flat Top Box” Bootleg Vol. III: Live Around the World (2011)
- “Remember the Alamo” Bootleg Vol. III: Live Around the World (2011)
- “Long-Legged Guitar Pickin’ Man” Bootleg Vol. III: Live Around the World (2011)
- “Ring of Fire” Bootleg Vol. III: Live Around the World (2011)
- “Darling Companion” At San Quentin (1969)
- “A Boy Named Sue” At San Quentin (1969)
- “(There’ll Be) Peace in the Valley” At San Quentin (1969)
- Bob Dylan “Girl From the North Country” Nashville Skyline (1969)
- “The Folk Singer” (1968); The Bootleg Series Vol. 2: From Memphis to Hollywood (2011)
- “Cisco Clifton’s Fillin’ Station” From Sea to Shining Sea (1968)
- “Daddy Sang Bass” At Madison Square Garden (2002)
- “He Turned the Water Into Wine” The Gospel Music of Johnny Cash (2008) (or version from the February 11, 1970 episode of “The Johnny Cash Show” – not available in album format)
- “Sunday Morning Coming Down” (1970); The Johnny Cash Show (1970)
- “Girl From the North Country” (with Joni Mitchell) The Best of The Johnny Cash TV Show: 1969-1971 (2008)
- “Flesh and Blood” (1971); I Walk the Line (1970)
- “See Ruby Fall” (1969); Hello, I’m Johnny Cash (1970)
- “Wanted Man” Little Fauss and Big Halsy (1970)
- Johnny Cash & June Carter “If I Were a Carpenter” (1969); Hello, I’m Johnny Cash (1970)
- “Orphan of the Road” Man in Black (1971)
- “Singing in Vietnam Talking Blues” (1971); Man in Black (1971)
- “You’ve Got a New Light Shining in Your Eyes” (1971); Man in Black (1971)
- “The Battle of New Orleans” America: A 200-Year Salute in Story and Song (1972)
- “Don’t Go Near the Water” (1974); Ragged Old Flag (1974)
- “King of the Hill” Ragged Old Flag (1974)
- “Southern Comfort” Ragged Old Flag (1974)
- “My Old Kentucky Home (Turpentine and Dandelion Wine)” (1975); John R. Cash (1975)
- “That Silver Haired Daddy of Mine” På Österåker (1973)
- Johnny Cash & June Carter “The City of New Orleans” Johnny Cash and His Woman (1973)
- “Orleans Parish Prison” (1972); Murder (2000)
- “Mississippi Sand” A Thing Called Love (1972)
- “Nasty Dan” (1974 or ’75); The Stars Come Out on Sesame Street (1979)
- “Junkie” (1974); The Junkie and the Juicehead Minus Me (1974)
- “I Hardly Ever Sing Beer Drinking Songs” (1975); Look at Them Beans (1975)
- “One Piece at a Time” (1976); One Piece at a Time (1976)
- “City Jail” (1977); The Last Gunfighter Ballad (1976)
- “Give It Away” The Last Gunfighter Ballad (1976)
- “After the Ball” (1978); The Rambler (1977)
- “I Don’t Think I Could Take You Back Again” I Would Like to See You Again (1978)
- “Without Love” Rockabilly Blues (1980)
- “It Ain’t Nothing New Babe” Rockabilly Blues (1980)
- “Abner Brown” I Would Like to See You Again (1978)
- “Lay Me Down in Dixie” A Believer Sings the Truth (1979)
- “The Baron” (1981); The Baron (1981)
- “The Last Gunfighter Ballad” (1977); The Last Gunfighter Ballad (1976)
- “Cindy, I Love You” The Last Gunfighter Ballad (1976)
- “The Lily of the Valley” Personal File (2006)
- “No Earthly Good” Personal File (2006)
- “It Takes One to Know Me” Personal File (2006)
- “Highway Patrolman” Johnny 99 (1983)
- “Unwed Fathers” Rainbow (1985)
- “The Hobo Song” The Mystery of Life (1991)
- “Just the Other Side of Nowhere” Unearthed (2003)
- “Let the Train Blow the Whistle” American Recordings (1994)
- “Delia’s Gone” (1994); American Recordings (1994)
- “Bird on a Wire” American Recordings (1994)
- “Spiritual” Unchained (1996)
- The Highwaymen “Live Forever [acoustic demo version]” The Road Goes On Forever: 10th Anniversary Edition (2005)
- “Ghost Riders in the Sky” In Ireland (2009)
- “Solitary Man” American III: Solitary Man (2000)
- “Rowboat” Unchained (1996)
- “Memories Are Made of This” Unchained (1996)
- “Country Boy” Unchained (1996)
- “I’ve Been Everywhere” Unchained (1996)
- “Country Trash” American III: Solitary Man (2000)
- “Field of Diamonds” American III: Solitary Man (2000)
- “Mary of the Wild Moor” American III: Solitary Man (2000)
- Johnny Cash & Willie Nelson “Unchained” VH1 Storytellers (1998)
- “Do Lord” Unearthed (2003)
- “I’ll Fly Away” Unearthed (2003)
- “Redemption Song” (with Joe Strummer) Unearthed (2003)
- “Help Me” American V: A Hundred Highways (2006)
A guide to gaining an introduction to gospel music (read: afro-american gospel music). When you get down to it, gospel is the rosetta stone of american music, and there are few styles of american music that haven’t either influenced gospel or taken influence from it. Hopefully the religious content of the music doesn’t keep people away. You can be indifferent or even openly hostile to religion and still enjoy this powerful music.
Various Artists Collections
Broad overview sets:
All things considered, this may be the best historical overview of gospel music I’ve seen yet, rivalled or surpassed only by the Jubilation! series mentioned below. There is definitely a good amount of material from the “golden age of gospel” in the 1950s here, which is something lots of other gospel box sets inexplicably omit. At four discs, there is a ton of great stuff from a lot of different periods and styles. This set does stop in the middle of the 1950s though, so you don’t get much if anything anything from the 1960s onward. But you might want to decide if you like gospel enough first before delving into the 1960s and 70s stuff. And for an introduction it’s probably best to avoid contemporary gospel anyway.
Jubilation! Volumes 1 & 2 make up probably the best two-disc introduction to gospel available, and together are probably my number one recommendation for someone just beginning to listen to gospel. Vols. 1 & 2 represent just about all of the major gospel talents, and the song selection is outstanding. Truly a superb set. The only caveat I would add is that the focus here is more on modern gospel, and little space is reserved for early 20th Century gospel, but that is actually a good approach for an introductory set like this.
Another great collection of material, similar to Vol. 1. You will really want to investigate both Vols. 1 & 2, though you could easily start with either one. There is a Vol. 3, but it focuses on country gospel, which is not the focus of this guide.
The first of a seven-album series, apparently available only as a digital download (in the USA at least). It features some great stuff from a variety of eras. There is a bit more non-quartet, folk/blues material here than many gospel collections.
Gospel Music (2006)
Bob Marovich review: http://www.theblackgospelb…golden-age.html
Like Get Right With God (see below), Fire in My Bones focuses on great but lesser-known recordings. In a way it’s a kind of alternate history of modern age gospel, documenting especially its vital and continuing tradition of do-it-yourself recordings. This also covers quite a large time frame (more than six decades). With some of the basics under your belt, this is a fun and exciting extension to delve deeper into the genre. The obscurity of the recordings means there is little overlap with other gospel compilations. A follow-up collection was released as This May Be My Last Time Singing: Raw African-American Gospel on 45RPM, 1957-1982, but definitely start with Fire in My Bones.
Goodbye, Babylon (2003)
Testify!: The Gospel Box (1999)
The Essential Gospel Sampler (1994)
My own “virtual” compilation.
More period-specific, stylistically-specific, or label-specific sets:
Awesome selection of early pre-WWII gospel. Lots of this stuff straddles the line between blues and gospel. Probably a less intimidating option than the Goodbye Babylon set, which seemed to borrow heavily from these selections because of the substantial overlap. Pair this set with the Gospel Music one above and you’ll get a fairly good overview of both old and modern gospel.
A set that focuses on jubilee gospel groups.
A collection of songs from some of the great gospel “quartets” (they often actually had more than four members) from primarily the later part of the 1940s but also some from the 1950s and one Soul Stirrers track from 1939. This actually picks up where the A Warrior On the Battlefield set leaves off, stylistically and chronologically. The liner notes are also quite good in explaining various aspects of the music and the personalities behind it.
The Gospel Sound (1994)
Specialty was the premier label for hard gospel quartets in the 1950s. I could quibble about some of the song selections here, but there is no doubt you get some great music and an introduction to most of the key groups on the Specialty label. Continued with Golden Age Gospel Quartets, Vol. 2 (1954-1963).
Awesome collection of mostly obscure stuff from the golden age. It’s all high-energy and really fun. The way this is assembled definitely reminds me of Harry Smith (who created the Anthology of American Folk Music), and what a collection of gospel from this period would probably sound like if he ever got around to putting one together.
Golden Age of Gospel (2001)
Gospel music played a big role in the 1950s/60s civil rights or freedom movement in the United States. Here’s an interesting look at that role.
Best of Nashboro Gospel (1995)
Gospel’s Finest (1992)
Individual Artist Selections
|People totally unfamiliar with gospel music may want to listen to a various artists collection first, but here are some single-artist selections that I find to be particularly worth checking out:|
The Golden Gate Quartet represents a different era than lots of other music on this list. They had jazz-inflected rhythms that stretched gospel beyond earlier forms, but compared to more modern acts the tempos were slower and there were not really any lead solos. But this is still great music. There are certainly plenty of different Golden Gate Quartet compilations available. This two-disc one seems to capture a lot of their best recordings, though in some ways it’s still incomplete.
The early Soul Stirrers with R.H. Harris were the single most influential gospel group. Ever. More than any other group, they blazed a trail away from the jubilee style that had dominated gospel for many decades–a style epitomized by The Golden Gate Quartet–and toward hard gospel of the 1950s. R.H. Harris made lead soloists the stars of gospel “quartets”, which had been expanded past just four members. This collection features a tremendous amount of really great music.
The best gospel of the 1940s is right here. Lead singer Ira Tucker was just unbelievably good. He was sort of gospel’s first “rock star” in my book. Maybe he was just the first rock star period, running down the aisles, jumping off stages…
Love Lifted Me / My Rock (1991)
Another great set of hard gospel from the 1950s.
Gospels, Spirituals & Hymns (1991)
|The Gospel Sound: Good News and Bad Times by Anthony Heilbut
How Sweet the Sound: The Golden Age of Gospel by Horace C. Boyer
Encyclopedia of American Gospel Music by W.K. McNeil (ed.)
Blues and Gospel Records: 1890-1943 by Robert M.W. Dixon, John Godrich, and Howard W. Rye
Gospel Records: 1943-1969 by Cedric W. Hayes and Robert Laughton
|Just Moving On Blog
The Black Gospel Blog
Holy Ghost Blog
Sinner’s Crossroads Radio Show
Black Gospel Collector’s Forum
The eponymous debut album by The Rolling Stones (renamed England’s Newest Hit Makers for subsequent U.S. release) is a somewhat inauspicious affair. It is full of energetic takes on American blues. The group plays with enthusiasm. Yet aside from a few hints at guitar prowess, there aren’t a whole lot of highlights here. Still, there aren’t any great missteps, and the effort to reach out across racial lines is admirable. This was about taking essentially rural music and making it more urban and palatable for middle class youth desperate for a new music to call their own. Perhaps that wasn’t the precise intent, but it was the ultimate effect. They got better quickly. What is stunning is how there are scarcely any cues here to indicate just how good they would get — or how fast they would get there.
Here is my take on a “virtual” single disc gospel overview compilation. Neophytes, I dare you to listen to this and not become a fan. I’ve tried to link up more readily available CD collections rather than hard-to-find LPs. Will be continued with my Gospel Mix, Part II, Gospel Mix, Part III, Gospel Mix, Part IV and Gospel Mix, Part V lists. In the interest of full disclosure, I am an atheist.
Rev. B.L. Wightman with Lottie Kimbrough & Congregation – “Live the Life”
Rev. Sister Mary Nelson – “Judgment”
Golden Gate Quartet – “Bedside of a Neighbor”
Richmond’s Harmonizing Four – “Everytime I Feel the Spirit”
Dixie Hummingbirds – “Move On Up a Little Higher [alt. take]”
I Want to Know (2006)
Love Lifted Me / My Rock (1991)
The Five Blind Boys of Mississippi – “(I’ll Be) In the Wilderness”
The Davis Sisters – “Jesus Steps Right In”
When Gospel Was Gospel (2005)
Get on Board (1992)
Sister O.M. Terrell – “I’m Going to that City”
Sister Rosetta Tharpe – “Cain’t [sic] No Grave Hold My Body Down”
Gospel Train (1956)
The Caravans – “Your Friend”
The Best of The Caravans (1998)
Gospels, Spirituals & Hymns (1991)
The Holmes Brothers – “I Shall Not Walk Alone”
Speaking in Tongues (2001)
Some bag on Stereopathetic Soulmanure as an inferior Beck release, but I think it’s easily one of his best albums. It’s a little rough in patches, but the eclectic songwriting is usually good and there is even some fairly good guitar playing. Beck is all over the place. From found sounds, to noise rock, to country, to folk, he tries a little of everything. But he manages to pull it off. In fact, Mellow Gold was a big step down from the creativity on display here. Beck hadn’t yet hooked up with hip-hop producers but it’s no real loss with what is found here. Is this juvenile? Yes, of course. But it manages to faithfully capture the sense of looking for something that resonates and finding the process of the search at least as interesting as anything found along the way. This has the feel of bored Southern California kids making their own entertainment — not unlike what Ariel Pink would do a few years later.